Posted by: chalupagoal | February 18, 2010

I’ll flip your lid if you flip mine

Gregg Drinnan notices the same thing that many Chiefs fans have:

It would seem that the next move is up to the WHL. Prior to the start of the season, the WHL implemented a helmet rule, prohibiting a player from taking off his own helmet before engaging in fisticuffs.
Recently, some players have incorporated new moves into their prefight routine. Each player will undo his own chinstrap, then they come together, with each player knocking off the other player’s helmet before any punches are thrown.
This all is very interesting and apparently within the rules as they presently are written. But I have a feeling that it won’t be long before that rule is rewritten, or the league comes up with a new one.
Still, let us give the players credit for originality.

I saw Beach do this a week or two ago, and thought it was a fairly ingenious way of getting around what lots of players consider to be a stupid and counter-productive rule. (Counterproductive because insisting on broken knuckles and hurt hands doesn’t improve the safety of the game from an enforcer or a self-policing perspective.)

Do you think the rules should be changed, or should players who agree to fight without helmets be allowed to carry on?

Advertisement

Responses

  1. The rule should be ousted.

  2. this rule doesn’t really make sense to me. In the NHL don’t the officials like helmet removal (especially for those with visors)?

    • I believe the NHL has the same rule, starting this year or last? And the venn diagram of guys with visors and guys who fight looks like two circles 10 feet apart.

  3. Removing the helmet prevents broken fingers and stitches in knuckles. If two guys decide to bash each other in the face, and there is no rule against two guys bashing each other in the face, why do you make a rule that interferes with that? Recockulous.

  4. yeah, and pretty soon the uniforms will look like the ones worn by those fellas in the olympics.

    TWO MINUTES FOR HOCKEYING!

    i don’t glorify fighting in general, but one must admit that there are strategic and psychological reasons for two guys squaring off (fairly). boys will be boys – so let them.

    • My general policy if both player agree to enter combat, let them. It’s a social contract thing. I understand how fighting factors in and I’m ok with that. Do I hate gong show and yard sale hockey? Yes. But there is a balance I think.


Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.